Theft, Fakes and Forgery...Understanding Art Crime in a Global Art Market

01 May 2017

According to Gareth Fletcher, who leads the London summer course on Art Crime and is an expert in art and its markets, there are three main facets to art crime:

Theft by deception - forgery, fakes, white-collar crime such as money laundering, the manipulation of ownership histories and the process of illicit trafficking of cultural objects. A recent Mutual Art article mentions an often-cited statistic that 10 percent of works in museums are fakes.

Theft by larceny - art theft and illegal acquisition of objects from museums/public collections. Historical antecedents of theft by larceny include iconic works - such as the well-known Mona Lisa or The Scream by Munch. Just recently, several works by Vincent Van Gogh were returned to the eponymous Dutch museum 14 years after they were stolen in a brazen heist.

Theft by destruction - socio-economic and political forces have had an impact upon material culture. Cultural restitution and spoliation is not merely a past issue, but lives today in ongoing court cases and the ravages of war-torn countries. For example, ArtNet recently reported on two busts destroyed by ISIS returning to Syria after they were restored in Italy by a novel method involving 3D printing and powerful magnets.         

The subject of art crime demands a thorough investigation to identify the threats and challenges it presents to our cultural and commercial institutions. In order to understand art crime, it is important to identify the broad range of illegal activities with the potential to emerge within the international art world. From legal and ethical challenges to economic and technological threats. art crime assumes a variety of forms, which makes it an exciting, mysterious and challenging phenomenon that demands further scrutiny.

The 2-week summer course on this subject will consider the cultural and economic impact of thefts from museums and galleries, and provide an insight into future technological approaches to analysing and authenticating important works of art. Visits to cultural institutions in London will provide the backdrop from which to identify fakes, forgeries, misattributions and replications, and increasingly important themes of cultural restitution and repatriation will continue to be discussed throughout the duration of the course. From understanding how art crime operates, to identifying and mitigate potential threats, this programme is an opportunity to help safeguard and preserve our collective cultural identity.

About Gareth Fletcher:

Gareth is a Lecturer and Seminar Tutor in Art Business at Sotheby’s Institute of Art. He contributes to a wide range of art business-related programmes and courses at the Institute, with a particular focus on restitution, provenance, authenticity and the law. He is the recipient of a TECHNE AHRC scholarship to pursue a PhD examining the semiotics of provenance as an institutional construct in the establishment of cultural and economic value in the market for Near Eastern antiquities. He has contributed a chapter on ‘Criminal Activity and Art: fakes, forgeries and thefts’ to the Sotheby’s Institute publication Art Business Today: 20 Key Topics

Source: Sotheby's Instute of Art


Theft, Fakes and Forgery...Understanding Art Crime in a Global Art Market